anime that ruined the manga adaptations

Top 15 Anime That Ruined The Manga Worst Adaptation Ever

Lots of best-selling Japanese manga get turned into anime.

Diehard fans cross their fingers hoping that their special series will transform into animated wonders, capturing the magic found within the pages of the original books.

However, frustrations arise when studios anime that ruins the manga elements that readers hold special.

Today I’ll analyze 15 anime that ruined the manga cases where popular anime productions arguably face-planted honoring the spirit of sensational source manga.

15 Worst Anime Adaptations Of Popular Manga

Berserk (1997)

berserk anime that ruined the manga

IMDB: 8.9
Genres: Action, Adventure, Demons, Supernatural, Military
Studio: OLM
Where to Watch: Crunchyroll

What Went Wrong:

Kentaro Miura’s gruesome dark medieval fantasy masterpiece Berserk won global fame through its demonic brutality and complex political arcs spanning 40+ volumes since 1989.

But fans protest how early anime adaptations severely rush through plot points and time jumps that took the book’s deliberate effort to establish full dramatic irony.

The 26-episode series skips substantive world-building, leaving viewers puzzled by unexplained shifts in character motives and kingdom alliances.

While it recreates some signature artwork shots, seeing guts over gore alone can’t carry Berserk’s profound emotional resonance built slowly on pages.

Tokyo Ghoul (2014)

tokyo ghoul worst anime adaptations Of popular manga

IMDB: 7.9
Genres: Action, Drama, Horror, Psychological, Supernatural
Studio: Pierrot
Where to Watch: Funimation, Hulu

What Went Wrong:

Creeping body horror melodrama Tokyo Ghoul hooked readers through its vampiric concepts crashing against relatable college characters questioning compulsions.

But fans protest how the 12 episode sprint condenses so much rich setup introducing investigator agency dynamics and societal structures organizing hunter cells later battles hinge on.

We needed more room to establish internal precedent for seismic reveals later that now seem to appear from nowhere without proper context earning audience investment in outcomes.

The Promised Neverland (2019)

the-promised-neverland

IMDB: 8.2
Genres: Mystery, Psychological, Supernatural, Thriller
Studio: CloverWorks
Where to Watch: Hulu, Crunchyroll, Funimation

What Went Wrong:

Posuka Demizu and Kaiu Shirai’s acclaimed orphanage escape thriller The Promised Neverland utterly hooked fans with constant ominous tension and bonds between endearing kid characters. But many readers decry how the anime team severely rushes through the initial mystery world building.

Early friendship scenes bonding sisters Emma and Norman get trimmed when that earned emotional weight should’ve built suspense later for their horrific revelations to hit harder. Neverland’s gradual narrative boil needed room landing turns.

Related:

Good Shows Gone Bad: 15 Anime Series With Disappointing Ending

Black Butler (2008)

berserk anime that ruined the manga

IMDB: 7.9
Genres: Action, Comedy, Demons, Supernatural, Historical
Studio: A-1 Pictures
Where to Watch: Funimation, Hulu, Netflix

What Went Wrong:

Yana Toboso’s ongoing period revenge thriller Black Butler bewitches through slow-burn occult mysteries and charmingly demonic aesthetics.

But fans argue the initial anime adaptation struggled to establish narrative relationships clearly early enough to appreciate layered dynamics before sudden stakes arise requiring that understanding.

For example, scrubbing Sebastian’s subtle sarcasm erodes sinister charisma carrying contracts forwards. And brief references later to Ciel’s past trauma-driving quests for vengeance rings hollow when the gruesome extent was never portrayed justifying personal costs tying goals such as those to darkest demons.

Rosario + Vampire (2008)

rosario-vampire

IMDB: 7.2
Genres: Comedy, Ecchi, Fantasy, Harem, Romance, Vampire
Studio: Gonzo
Where to Watch: Funimation, Crunchyroll, Tubi

What Went Wrong:

Goofy supernatural teen comedy Rosario + Vampire attracted readers through its playful parody take on school monster genres.

But fans protest how liberal anime fan service insertions severely undermine manga’s signature self-aware charm.

As source author Akihisa Ikeda admits regretting overly embarrassed emphasis on lurid content diminishes affection for serial progression itself later.

I can’t blame readers miffed seeing creative works misrepresented resulting in softened occasional raunchiness eclipsing smarter plotting and debatably more defining overall.

Deadman Wonderland (2011)

deadman wonderland

IMDB: 7.4
Genres: Action, Horror, Sci-Fi
Studio: Manglobe
Where to Watch: Hulu, Funimation

What Went Wrong:

Macabre death game thriller Deadman Wonderland is a R-rated anime that immediately disturbed readers through grotesque sentencing and diabolical confinement horrors after debuting in 2007.

But despite wicked concepts realized visually quite faithfully, fans blast the anime team harshly condensing necessary establishment phases defining institutional history and backstories fueling despicable desperations later twisting affairs to life and death stakes.

That vital context rushed denies the audience empathy appreciating inhuman acts eventually committed by those introduced initially shorthanded instead of given room earning dimensional paths taken rather than conveniently presumed right away.

Related:

Best 15 Action-Packed Shounen Anime Series to Watch In 2023

Yu-Gi-Oh! (1998)

yu-gi-oh anime that ruined the manga adaptations

IMDB: 7.4
Genres: Action, Comedy, Fantasy, Supernatural, Tournament
Studio: Gallop
Where to Watch: Crunchyroll, Hulu, Tubi

What Went Wrong:

When Kazuki Takahashi’s original Yu-Gi-Oh! the manga launched in Shonen Jump from 1996-2004, its occult detective thriller roots pioneered the global gaming empire before spin-off series continued milking card game appeal exclusively over decades.

But disgruntled fans protest heavily how the anime adaptations severely downplay richer horror lore and violence framing legendary card’s significance early on in favor of reformatting things for younger viewers.

By over-emphasizing repetitive tournament spectacle while removing mature darker content connecting gameplay contextually to life and death purpose originally, studios spoiled a phenomenal premise losing dramatic traction honoring its more ominous complex narrative spirit by commercially chasing trends instead.

The Seven Deadly Sins (2014)

the seven deadly sins

IMDB: 8
Genres: Action, Adventure, Fantasy, Magic, Supernatural
Studio: A-1 Pictures
Where to Watch: Netflix

What Went Wrong:

Acclaimed fantasy action epic The Seven Deadly Sins blends beautifully stylized fights with endearing rapport between its titular knights bound by prophecy reclaiming lost kingdom legacies.

But despite praise aimed at Studio Deen’s inaugural adaptation courting mainstream appeal, longtime fans protest later seasons severely declining in production values as iconic battles get reduced to slideshow fast forwards far skimpier than Nakaba Suzuki’s manga artwork portrayed with fluid spectacle.

Beyond glory visuals alone, truncating early relationship dimensions strains credibility for personal stakes raised together against external threats far later down plotlines.

Black Clover (2017)

black clover anime that ruined the manga

IMDB: 8.2
Genres: Action, Comedy, Magic, Fantasy, Shounen
Studio: Pierrot
Where to Watch: Funimation, Crunchyroll

What Went Wrong:

Despite skyrocketing sales lifting Yuki Tabata’s underdog magic adventure Black Clover rapidly towards crossover mainstream notice, loyal day-one manga fans recoiled initially at the production corner cutting marring earlier anime adoption efforts and underwhelming their cravings.

Cheap panning shots recycled far too frequently deflate dynamic action translating vibrantly fearsome battles literally shown innovatively across pages.

Anime-original filler arcs delaying the main plot turn off readers awaiting delving properly into wider magical world building mythos making this Shounen franchise uniquely its own.

The unambitious adaptation risks wasting still untapped narrative potential leaving viewers divided on whether true series spirit got served.

Related:

Best Succubus Anime- Demon Girls Causing Mischief!

Blade of the Immortal (2008)

blade of the immortal

IMDB: 7.7
Genres: Action, Adventure, Drama, Historical, Martial Arts, Samurai
Studio: Bee Train Production
Where to Watch: Hulu, iTunes

What Went Wrong:

But critics jeer Bee Train studio’s 2008 rendition dwelling solely on lavish slasher spectacle while outright omitting symbolic emotional explorations defining the long-running saga’s wasted potential true artistry.

Many laud Hiroaki Samura’s gripping Chanbara revenge tragedy Blade of the Immortal among top graphic feats framing pulpy swordplay action within nuanced characterization transcending genre conventions since first debuting way back in 1993.

Reducing protagonists to hollow contextless shells amidst mindless dismemberment tanks narrative resonance and thematic ambition that should have aligned anime adaption with source material timelessness.

D.Gray-man (2016)

d-gray-man manga that were actually ruined by the anime adaptation

IMDB: 7.8
Genres: Action, Adventure, Comedy, Super Power, Demons
Studio: TMS Entertainment
Where to Watch: Funimation, Hulu

What Went Wrong:

Despite running strong across manga pages since debuting in 2004, Hoshino Katsura’s acclaimed supernatural war epic D.Gray-man struggles to find international anime footing.

Attempts rearranging religious action arcs thematically core on paper approach incoherence on-screen straddling continuity.

Fans argue committed courses separating narrative bounds may have communicated dynamics easier than perpetually unfinished seasons trying to keep pace with creator health woes stalling output yet delivering anyway.

Sticking manga structured storylines first could have honored epic scope hard conveying compressed overall.

Fruits Basket (2001)

fruits basket Worst Anime Adaptations Of Popular Manga

IMDB: 7.6
Genres: Comedy, Drama, Romance, Supernatural
Studio: Studio Deen
Where to Watch: Crunchyroll, Funimation, Hulu

What Went Wrong:

Critically revered as a transcendent shoujo achievement, Takaya Natsuki’s decades-spanning Fruits Basket dynasty fixates on broken souls bonded by fate finding family salvation from ancestral curses.

But reception soured towards anime reboots hurriedly maximizing melodrama milestones before adequately establishing interpersonal conditions ripening those moments to land emotionally invested.

Brief seasons struggle to convey gradual nurturing subtly setting manga’s melancholic masterpiece apart.

Anime truncation trades nuanced character writing for the hollow tragic reveal that should have culminated from thoughtful groundwork laying necessary underneath first.

Related:

Top 10 R-rated Anime Movies List: Discovering the Adult Side

The Flowers of Evil (2013)

the flowers of evil

IMDB: 7.0
Genres: Drama, Psychological, Romance, School
Studio: Zexcs
Where to Watch: Crunchyroll, RetroCrush

What Went Wrong:

Distinctly disturbing psychological coming-of-age drama The Flowers of Evil tested genre tastes through Shuzo Oshimi’s provocative teenage struggles examining innocence corrupted – thematically juxtaposed against pastoral beauty ironically framing sullying ugliness.

But fans recoiled over the rotoscoped 2013 anime adaptation forsaking sly illustrated symbolism outright stating the obvious instead.

Art that realistically shows ugly or disturbing things can make moral questions less clear. This is different from manga or cartoons that have a more innocent, stylized look.

The realistic art contrasts with the nice things in nature. It makes you think about what is good or bad in a complicated way, not just simple opposites.

Gantz (2004)

gantz anime that ruined the manga

IMDB: 7.2
Genres: Action, Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, Supernatural, Psychological
Studio: Gonzo
Where to Watch: Netflix, Plex

What Went Wrong:

Brutal sci-fi cult classic Gantz fused social commentary examining mortality and morality between gratuitous spectacle spanning dozens of provocative volumes since debuting in 2000 from Hiroya Oku.

But fans jeer anime adaptations mostly forsaking layered philosophic themes questioning situational ethics in favor of solely maximizing lurid elements instead like violence and erotica exceeding necessary levels.

Slick visuals accurately convey mature dynamics matter less absent narrative ambition further examining societal assumptions through dangerous games testing human nature once pushing readers immersed evaluating what justifies survival means when pit against others unwillingly.

Hellsing (2001)

hellsing anime that ruined the manga

IMDB: 7.5
Genres: Action, Horror, Military, Vampire, Supernatural
Studio: Gonzo
Where to Watch: Funimation, Tubi

What Went Wrong:

Legendary horror visionary Kohta Hirano first unleashed Hellsing chronicling occult agents battling supernatural conspiracies in 1997 to instant acclaim across manga and anime mediums internationally.

But fans protest how Studio Gonzo’s project compromises complex themes of necessary evil downplaying intricate politics and characterizations associated with applauded epic for shock value spectacle alone.

Lavish backdrops can’t disguise diminishing plot returns redirecting around meaningless monster mayhem inserted decreasing intrigue sustainability.

Iconography without intricate intensity flounders honoring Hellsing’s seminal influence pioneering darker storylines and changing mainstream acceptance.

Does insult aim above at anime not transcending amazing manga feel warranted? What bungled adaptations aggrieve you? Share suggestions below for coverage ideas on divisions between beloved books underrepresented transitioning screens supposedly meant celebrating them!

Scroll to Top